I wouldn’t go for either, because with Althaïr by Parfums de Marly and Lafayette Street by Bond No 9 you allready have quiet a bit of vanillic scents. But maybe the question is: what do you miss in your collection? Is it more a tropical, a sweet, an aromatic, a vanilla? If you could give us a more detailed idea of what you search for we can maybe give a better or more ideal recommandation. :-)