Something about Man in Red is redeeming it and pulling it back from falling into the gaping precipice that is my wrath. It escapes it's fate in the yawning chasm for one reason...it goes straight for my inner child and more specifically that child's sweet tooth. I can't believe that vanilla isn't listed because it dries down very soft and creamy. (Just noticed Tonka is listed) The opening however made me really dislike it with that mundane fruity apple vibe and fruity woods. The accord does grow on me after a while as I said and it's pretty in explicable because I really shouldn't like it but I do. I get the comparision to the red Dunhill one but this is even sweeter and softer.