fragrances
reviews
903 reviews
This is modern perfume hyperbole, so strong it should be impossible. One tiny dab somewhere on your person is MORE than enough, and 10ml will last a lifetime. Personally I'm sick of the dearth of akigalawood Bischs but this one is one of the best. I can't decide if it's more or less brutal than Tubéreuse Astral, I think more.
A dash of Fils de Joie with the dank papyrus from Figment Woman, old school plum in a supporting (but restrained role) and fruity ylang ylang. Amouage is my favourite house for a reason, every composition is a triumph (I'm taking Chong era and before, recently there are highs and lows), and this is no exception.
Incredíble opening which goes from Guerlain to generic Xerjoff crap within 1 hour. Cheap synthetic oud accord. Boring, screechy and bland, great opening though. Update: every now and then I try this again, from my official 10ml miniature. It really is awful, offensive even when you consider the price. It smells cheap, aggressively synthetic (the comparison to slowdive is a joke surely!) and grating, and it only gets worse as it dries down. What else could we possibly expect when the house is making one perfumer churn out hundreds of perfumes a year. How the mighty have fallen!
Tested in the boutique today, on card and on my skin.
The opening seems delicate, but in fact this is super strong, heavy honey. It's VERY similar to Tobacolor, too close to warrant buying it, for me at least, as I already own the latter.
At home I put one on each arm and they're indistinguible. Perhaps Dior has a very slightly richer opening, but after an hour they're identical to my nose.
Fully synthetic smelling. No oud, as with other Guerlains. If they're using oud, it's trace amounts just to say it's there, and this one doesn't smell remotely like oud. People who talk about "the oud" in this perfume haven't smelled oud. Very strong cardamom (like the opening of Épices Exquises) with some fig and patchouli and an enormous whack of sandalwood aroma-chemicals (I'm getting a LOT of stemone and probably janavol). This type of thing is fine, but the price is criminal considering you can buy perfumes with real oud and real mysore sandlewood in them which smell infinitely more beautiful and special and which cost the same or less per ml.
VERY strong, lasts eternally on my skin. The feel is extremely similar to the dry down of Œillet Pourpre, which I prefer. This one is a little sweet. Very heavy on the Guerlinade.
I bet $1000 dollars this is by Bisch. Update: OK so it's not. Smells boring as shit though.
I have the vintage one with the loose, ivory looking cap, and it's incredible. Strong, long-lasting and complex, I absolutely love it. The first two hours remind me of Tom Ford for Men but with way better ingredients and with the incense-floral amouage twist. It's less the smell that's the resemblance than the feel of the perfume (I came home and sprayed one on each arm and they're very different but of the same ilk). The drydown goes in a direction I wouldn't have seen coming save for some reviews here. It becomes fluffy and floral, with the creamy frankincense ebbing away underneath, absolutely gorgeous, and a credit to the perfumer because on card, I detect some sort of stinky synthetic just for a few seconds in the opening (not on skin) so this could easily have been one of the pantheon of perfumes which degenerate into some blah generic woody amber base. Here, it couldn't be further from that. This is beautiful, top-notch perfumery. It's eminently wearable in any conditions, unlike a lot of Amouages, so for me that's a real score too. Shame this 50ml will probably be my first and last due to how discontinued AF it is. It's worth noting that the pyramid above doesn't really represent the experience of smelling this perfume. All the notes are there, but it's very united, one exquisitely crafted scent, very old-school, no overload of any one thing like everyone does now.
The opening 5 mins I found a bit of a struggle, as I always do with perfumes which combine boozy and fruity aspects, plus I tend to struggle with osmanthus, but then it starts to turn more serious, like a leathery tobacco or something, and I really love it. I swear it smells like there's some tobacco in here, raw, moist tobacco. The boozy, spicy side makes it sort of mouthwatering, it's incredible. I'm not sure what genre I'd put this in, it's a genre-bender for sure, as there's almost something a bit gourmand about it. It's more dynamic than Narcis Nocturne, I'm getting something different every few minutes. Now, in the drydown, it's pipe tobacco on a old desk in a library of leather-bound tomes covered in dust with a glass of maybe absinthe?! Lol, awesome!
Very natural-smelling narcissus. If I think about the seperate notes I can discern them but actually this is more of a harmonious smell that evokes the natural flower itself. The oakmoss is old-school, not sure how she did that! It does smell modern but it puts me in mind of vintage florals from the days when they weren't scared to go for it. It's very yellow and has a twinge of pissy, honeyish sweetness, absolutely lovely!
No doubt this is an incredible endeavour, a feat of perfumery.
It's a warm Autumn Sunday, I've been for a run and am lounging in the sunlight watching TV wearing EdC. I keep sniffing myself, it's compelling, but I also feel like I've scattered salad all over my prostrate body. Lettuce, tomato, cucumber and maybe some herby olive oil.
I don't think I'd ever wear this
Wonderful, classic Ellena.
A blind buy for me after listening to a Fragrantica talks episode, and I don't regret it.
Probably not the best performance, but it's Ellena so I've come to expect that, plus sometimes subtle and ephemeral is what I'm going for. (Update: performance is actually pretty impressive for this type of scent, it sits close, but is enduring)
It doesn't smell like Eau d'Hiver, but what they have in common is the sort of distant, caught-on-the-breeze délicatesse, and they both give me the impression that this is how these notes work, i.e. you don't want them presenting as loud, beasty and screechy.
Ellena's perfumes are the antithesis of Tom Ford for me, I'm glad they both exist but this is the high art to Tom Ford's cartoonish output.
Blooms in heat, when the tomato leaf is a bit less dominant.