This one opens woody with a citrus blend, perhaps that grapefruit again? I actually think there's a peppery, light smoked hint of cedar at the back of this and if it was just cedar and citrus I'd probably accuse it of being boring or cliched, so I can't have it both ways. (Well actually you can just make a better fragrance!!) however, the vanilla makes the whole thing a bit smooshy...not offended as such, I just don't like it and I'm not a fan.