fragrances
avaliação
903 avaliações
Not his best work. It smells great in the opening, a salty, savoury freshie which in every other respect fits the MFK standard format of musk plus freshie top. Unfortunately, in the dry down (which lasts forever) I get a sort of dry, droning synthetic wood smell, not unlike what many charlatans call "oud". The fennel note also persists forever, but whereas it charmed me at first, without the magic freshness it just becomes a flat, kitcheny smell that doesn't appeal to me. A dud compared to his many other wondeful freshie perfumes.
I know there's no tobacco absolute in this, and Liz M created a tobacco accord, but I don't smell anything like tobacco. What I get is a sticky, honeyed rose with a hefty real ambergris base. On my skin it smells like a Dusita, reminding me of Rosarine and Oudh Infini, though it's more restrained than those perfumes. It's a lovely perfume with many facets unfolding delicately over time, but not one I feel is for me.
First thoughts are that I didn't realise Nishane had ever put out such a classic, refined and complex chypre perfume. A few hours after wearing, I forgot what I'd been wearing and was smelling myself, entranced, like what the hell is this amazing perfume, then I remembered. It's a journey, as the opening, mid and drydown smell totally distinct. It's a real gem, and the only people making this type of thing these days are small artisan niche houses if you're lucky.
Spectacular. I'm surprised, having read the reviews here, by the strength of the ambergris. On me it's massive, alongside the citrus and florals. Bortnikoff does not disappoint as far as I'm concerned! It's similar in construction to Silver Man, in that it's a deep, rich take on the traditional cologne formula, and it also shares a lot in common with Reflection Man, in that it has a mid phase where the jasmine is booming out, with neroli/orange blossom playing second fiddle. Side note: if like me you found Amouage Ashore to be a good idea horribly executed, this is doing the same thing (jasmine and ambergris) without the horrible aggressive synthetic side that ruins Ashore.
Very similar to Habit Rouge (which I absolutely hate). This is better though... Still not sure if it's for me but it's not making me feel enraged like HR does (yes yes, I know it's a good perfume but let's be serious, it's unwearable). Update after hours of wear: Opening is Habit Rouge, then it transitions to Habit Rouge mixed with Reflection Man, before settling into a droning, eternal drydown of the worst elements of both of those fragrances. Not sure what it is but it gives me everything I hate about Habit Rouge and more. It's a hard pass for me but perhaps fans of HR will like this beast mode version. Bleurgh.
100 times better on skin than on card. Bears no resemblance to the notes listed, it's more an earthy leather with possibly some herbs and geranium, plus lots of patchouli.
While I'll give this one credit for being one of the only scents by this godawful house that doesn't seem to be a clone of some previous popular perfume, it does however smell like a kid vomited popcorn debris over a leather car interior. So perhaps stick to copying other perfumes, eh, mind games? What a turkey.
The more time passes with this bottle I get strong musk, plus all the other notes but barely a trace of oud. This is not a problem, because it's beautiful, but I've smelled a sample of the Autumn 2019 version and it has a huge cheesey oud for the first hour which is totally missing from my version (gold edged box, flacon with metal ribbed cap). Coming back to it again, the citrus is harsh and cleaner-like at the top. I have many Bortnikoff scents and this is probably my least favourite now. I like it less the more I have worn it over the last year.
Opening: glorious sour, almost stewed orange but with a bit of sparkle from the pepper and bergamot, possibly a touch of cheesey oud (maybe that's what's making the orange seem sour) and non-indolic jasmine with cardamom to smooth it out . Whereas I almost always percieve all notes in a given pyramid at once, this genuinely gives me only the opening notes (OK, plus the oud which is already there). The perfume keeps undulating and wafting out different elements, and seamlessly tránsitions to the mid: here the rose and clove comes through, with a sort of warming effect from the magnolia and tonka. I don't perceive the frangipani necessarily but I'm sure I'd miss it if it were gone. Maybe it's giving the creaminess... Now the tart blast of the orange has calmed down and it's become a sort of pomander with the clove, but the rose and other florals stop it from seeming festive. I'm trying to find a context that the smell evokes, but aside from sharing Bortnikoff DNA with other scents, it's totally unique. There are natural, almost agrestic elements to the way the florals come across, but also the opulence I expect from the house, an opulence with transcends showiness, money, brashness, and instead is just marvelous and elegant, an all-seasons class act who is also friendly and down to earth. The dry down: the sun sets and the perfume turns darker, but still retaining the sumptuous, semi-gourmand charm. The magnolia starts to dominate the floral side, and there's something woody or vetiver-like, but I think this may be a facet of the oud(s). Something else starts to pique my taste buds, birch tar! And there's a magic something or other I can quite place, which is when I remember there's natural musk in here, as I suddenly recall other natural musk perfumes, giving a fluffy buffer to the dark wooden edges. The real civet perhaps provides a slightly sharp, urinous twang, which I attibuted to the florals at first. It's an astounding perfume, even if you didn't like it, I think you'd recognise the staggering complexity. It's also rather more restrained that some of his other perfumes, making it wearable in most situations, while still having stellar performance. It's not gonna offend or choke anyone out.
Bland as hell, totally forgettable
Smells most strongly of burning plastic, then the listed notes. Coming back to it, I realise I love it actually.