fragrances
件のレビュー
903 件のレビュー
This stuff is simply divine, smells like Spiced Rum with a dash of cola, but not in a cheap, crass way. It's also very woody, which stops it being insipid, and the patchouli is perfect.
Astoundingly beautiful. The opening is a dazzling, crazy fanfare of florals, grapefruit and pâtisserie, which is lovely, but it's only right that this doesn't go on for too long, as it would definitely wear thin very quickly. I have to echo what many others have said, that it soon transitions into a creamy sandlewood and lotus scent, but this part is just DIVINE to me. Yes, it sits very close to the skin, but when you're up close, the sandalwood is pretty strong, and I think if it projected more it would ruin the delicate beauty of the scent bubble. I'm very familiar with the smell of dragon blood resin, and while it is here, it's not the main player in the scent. I wouldn't necessarily identify it if I wasn't looking for it, it just serves to provide a sort of nutty, tart sweetness to the sandalwood.
Something nauseating lurks in here, not sure what's doing that to me, but an otherwise pretty scent is repulsing me, but very subtly. I'll update this when I've got my head around it (or scrubbed it off, could go either way). ... OK I really don't like this, the pear is extremely synthetic and clashes with the other notes. The honey (not that I could identify it as such) is more of a vague agrestic sweetness than a honey note. The rose is the best part of this, but it's ruined by the juvenile, cloying, grating, and very linear fug of the rest of it.
Kurky already did this, and he did it way better, with Rose Barbare.
As always with a Bortnikoff, I'm immediately taken by the sheer quality and beauty of the ingredients. The initial blast gives me shimmering, dry bergamot with, of course, HUGE rose (Serge Lutens style, jammy and playful) and HUGE pink pepper, but also a strange, addicting woody undertone, not the oud, I think it's actually cedar. This is a cedar I don't normally encounter. As I'm trying to pin down what the wood is, the sandalwood starts to show up. This is where you really know you have something special. It smells like sticking your nose up close to a lump of raw sandalwood (which I have done recently at the Chanel exhibition in Paris). It's creamy, rich, ancient-seeming, and almost, but not quite, gourmandy. The oud is there all the while, but this isn't an oud perfume, it's a sandalwood marvel. I've just bought La Fille Tour de Fer, and there is a link here, with the natural smelling rose and pink pepper, but this one is the grand dame of the genre, while the lutens is a very respectable affordable rose perfume.
Amazing stuff, not too far away from Memoir Man. Both have been brutally reformulated so try to get an old batch. My Memoir Woman is from 2018, and it's darker, more resinous and less fruity than the recent iteration. This might go against it for some, but for me it's exactly what I want. It does bear some of the Poison DNA, although when you smell them side by side they are worlds apart (sort of similar in connection to Fate Woman alongside Opium). It lacks the greeness and vanilla of the men's version, instead being warm and resiny (similar resinous base to Interlude Woman), and is not quite as loud. The notion that either of them is masculine or feminine is moot to me. These are olfactive artworks, not easy to wear perhaps, but an absolute joy to those who get it. If you feel it, it will suit you, if not, it will probably wear you and make you uncomfortable, as with many Amouage perfumes. One of the things I love about this, is that as it develops over time, little delicate elements come in, like white florals (tuberose!), rose, grapey jasmine underpinning it all (and smelling almost like plum hence the nod to Poison), but they're all swirling around, so every sniff brings something different, deep and rich or impish and playful, it's masterful.
Nothing whatsoever like Leather Jardin, which is a great perfume in its own right.
Positives - it goes on a journey, changing constantly and indeed at certain times does remind me of the back room of Ikea with the woody smell. It smells like it contains quality ingredients, and has so many nods to other fragrances (mostly Amouages) that it's fun to experience as a perfume nerd. Negatives - it smells like everything and nothing. While I found it interesting to identify the perfumes it reminded me of over the course of its development (A*Men, Lyric Man, Epic Man, New York Intense, 3eme Homme, Ebène Fumé, Lyric Woman, etc etc), it never really settled into anything cohesive I could work with (update: what it does actually settle into for a more sustained period of time is Ebène Fumé, which I already own, and which is great, but old news). It has no edge, no hook, nothing to intrigue or challenge. Anything which could have provided some grit has been smoothed into oblivion, providing something which smells like an Initio but with good ingredients. Within 30 minutes it becomes a relentless woody drone. I said it's similar to Ebene Fumé, but it lacks the charm of that perfume. This is brah beastmode screech, albeit with much better quality ingredients than its counterparts (Initio and Parfums de Marly). This is Amouage now, imitating the brands where creative perfumery goes to die. And yes, it has (surprise surprise) that sludgy element to the base structure, as with all recent Amouage releases. I guess it boosts the sillage but it makes for an extremely obnoxious up-close experience, and you know you're in it for the long haul, scrub or no scrub. I find this trend very tiresome, as it means these perfumes all have the same feel, almost as if they're all flankers of one thing (some Bisch or the other). Fans of the likes of Purpose 50 will probably absolutely love this, but personally I find it to be another nail in the Amouage coffin... there's a woody pun in there somewhere.
Update: the screechy amberwood base is even more apparent to me now. It's criminal for a perfume this expensive to fall apart into cheap aroma-chemicals so quickly.
My experience with this perfume is the same as with all others from this brand. They're very skilfully made perfumes with extremely cheap ingredients, and it really shows when you wear them for a few hours. I love the opening of this one. It gives me dusty iris with interesting culinary elements, with a light skanky undercurrent, sort of wrong and naughty. Sadly this all falls apart pretty quickly and it becomes a droning woody aromatic with no further evolution or intrigue. Don't get me wrong, it's fine for the price, but I'd rather wear something better that cost me perhaps 50 euros more. There are cheapies out there that make my heart skip a beat, but this is definitely not one of them.
Fragrant, dry lavender with smoky patchouli and a pineapple that's so ripe it's basically rotting, absolutely fabulous. I was lucky enough to snag a flacon from 2018. While the modern version smells good, it's not the same anymore. This is old school with a capital N for niche. Look for an old batch, you won't regret it. As it unfolds, the trademark Malle geranium steps forward, as seen in GPM and Noir Épices. I don't really get any sugar or caramel, but there is a sweetness, more of a natural fruit sweetness. There's some sort of musky, armpit/crotch funk under it all. Masterpiece.
Unadulterated rose with a splash of iris and a sprinkle of pepper (I suspect more but it manages to keep it minimal so you can revel in the rose). It manages to be both simple and dazzling, classic yet unique. For me it's the best SL rose, as I've always craved a jammy rose like this that a) isn't sweet b) isn't alongside patchouli, cacao, oud, vanilla, or any other common distractions c) isn't lipsticky/makeup baggy d) is uncomplicated enough to layer when you want that dash of true rose e) isn't expensive (I paid 45 euros) f) has that special something to snag you in and this ticks all the boxes.