Sadly it is just not strong enough for me, it a beautiful sent, but just not enough ... Punch
I wanted to try this for the longest time and very nearly bought it blind due to the amazing bottle, have to say I'm glad I didn't. Although I don't find it overly feminine it does have a floral element which points toward it at times. Then with the sumptuous warm leather and it has a little spice from the incense it points more in a direction I like...mysterious if you like. It must be the rubbery balminess that completely puts me off this...I've never tried Bvlgari Black but the talk of rubber just makes me never want to. It's an interesting one and certainly not to be dismissed because it's such a mixture of notes there's probably something in there that's appeals but when you take the composition as a whole it isn't one I'll be adding to my collection...shame though I really wanted that bottle on my shelf.
Okay so this is a re review as I saw a 40ml bottle cheap and I love the bottle So much I wanted it for my collection despite not being mad on the smell the first couple of Tries. Well, I'm pleasantly surprised frankly whatever I didn't like about it originally was due to the Bvlgari black rubber comparisons which aren't here. The floral element was what I found prominent too and I can still really detect the lily of the valley after the initial opening of citrus. The Tonka is thick and easily the main player here as it dries down it becomes more and more leathery, problem is it's not a particularly sumptuous or like other leather fragrances I enjoy. So all in all I will wear this as it doesn't offend me but it doesn't excite me either.
If Guerlain did a Shalimar Milèsime Green Tea flanker this is what it would smell like. The leather is light and Guerlainy and there's a vanilla undertone perhaps something to do with the benzoin and/or tonka. Lovely, but not different enough for me to purchase a bottle (which in any case isn't possible now apparently). Very safe, and after 20 mins or so it becomes clear that the quality of Shalimar is lacking here.