What's clever about Dior and in particular The Homme line are the accords created by the mixture of notes to create a similar vibe and continuity throughout. For example the original Dior Homme has a mustiness which comes from the floral notes constantly fighting (in a good way) with the warm ambery, leathery, earthy heart. This one for me has the same thing but in a totally different citrus fragrance it's the sharp lemon and grapefruit in the top which is spiced with ginger and for me creates the same effect. Anyway...when it dries down this fragrance remains nice and fresh, as the ginger note (which I normally not overly keen on) mellows but is still present. I can see why people think it's over rated because there's lots of fresh citrus scents out there but few have the pedigree of this one in my opinion. It doesn't compare to Homme or Intense for legendary status and I don't know the cologne version well enough to compare with this other than it is a little softer. The verdict is...Dior fragrances are really well conceived and you can expect quality from their flankers.